Article Type : Original Article
Authors
1 Shahid Beheshti Hospital, Babol University of Medical Sciences, Babol, Iran
2 Nasibeh School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences, Sari, Iran
3 Amir-al-Momenin Hospital, Golestan University of Medical Sciences, Gorgan, Iran
4 Klinikum Rechts der Isar of the Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany
Abstract
This study aimed to evaluate the relationship between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept in children of veterans. This cross-sectional study, conducted in 2017 within Mazandaran province, Iran, focused on 150 children of veterans diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder. The instruments utilized for data collection in this investigation encompass demographic variables (such as gender, age, children's education level, father's education, mother's education, father's occupation, mother's occupation, and father's veteran percentage), the secondary traumatic stress scale, and the academic self-concept questionnaire. The mean scores for secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept among children of veterans were 43.97 (SD=13.8) and 40.52 (SD=17.09), respectively. Furthermore, a statistically significant correlation was observed between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept, indicating that an increase in secondary traumatic stress was associated with a decrease in academic self-concept (P<0.01). The findings of this study underscore a discernible correlation between secondary traumatic stress and the academic self-concept observed in the children of veterans. Notably, academic success emerges as a significant factor contributing to the enhancement of self-concept among this demographic.
Keywords
1 │ Introduction
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a psychiatric condition that arises in response to an overwhelming traumatic experience exceeding an individual's coping capacity [1]. This disorder is commonly associated with events of significant stress, such as warfare, natural disasters like floods and earthquakes, or instances of sexual assault [2]. Among these, warfare stands out as a prominent catalyst for the development of PTSD [3]. Notably, a substantial proportion of returning military personnel manifest symptoms indicative of this disorder [4]. The repercussions of PTSD, stemming from war-related incidents, extend beyond the affected individuals and exert adverse effects on the lives of their family members [5]. Remarkably, the psychological ramifications of war-related trauma may persist, manifesting complications more than three decades post-conflict [6].
Secondary traumatic stress represents a syndrome characterized by symptoms akin to PTSD, arising from prolonged exposure to an individual who has undergone psychological trauma related to warfare [7]. The ramifications of stress disorders after war-related incidents manifest in children and family members of veterans, who, as indirect victims of war, grapple with associated complications [8, 9]. In essence, the offspring of second-generation veterans comprise family members who bear witness to the complexities and injuries of war following their parents' experiences [10].
Secondary traumatic stress emerges as a significant post-war complication, with discernible symptoms and complications akin to PTSD evident in the offspring of affected individuals [11]. The progeny of veterans are susceptible to exposure to trauma-induced injuries, resulting in deleterious consequences across personal, social, and academic dimensions [12]. Psychological and emotional challenges constitute prevalent issues among the children of veterans afflicted by PTSD [13]. The enduring repercussions of war extend to emotional numbness, anger, and apprehension, as well as a spectrum of emotional and psychological adversities [14].
The progeny of veterans' wives commonly contend with academic challenges, marked by a decrease in academic motivation and a propensity for academic failure [15]. This phenomenon is attributed to the diminished learning rates and memory capabilities observed in the children of veterans, stemming from the recurrent stresses of life [16]. Consequently, academic underachievement and reduced self-esteem manifest in these individuals [17]. Conversely, a positive academic self-concept serves as a mitigating factor, fostering enhanced self-esteem and favorable psychological outcomes [18]. Academic self-concept, a pivotal non-cognitive variable, plays a crucial role in shaping students' attitudes toward school and influencing their academic performance [19]. It is integral to an individual's general self-concept, reflecting one's perceptions of personal abilities and limitations as a student. Notably, disruptions in an individual's overall self-concept correspondingly impact dimensions such as academic self-concept [12]. Grounded in this context, the symptoms of vicarious stress in the children of veterans are identified through a decline in self-esteem and a deterioration in academic performance [15]. Consequently, the researchers have investigated the correlation between secondary traumatic stress and the academic performance of the offspring of veterans afflicted by secondary-traumatic stress disorder.
2 │ Methods
2.1 │ Study design and subjects
This cross-sectional study, conducted in 2017 in Mazandaran province, Iran, focused on 150 children of veterans diagnosed with PTSD. The inclusion criteria encompassed children aged above 15 years, with fathers possessing a verified veteran record acknowledged by educational institutions due to stress resulting from a war-related incident. Additionally, participants were required to be free from chronic mental illness and presently residing with their parents. Exclusion criteria comprised the voluntary non-participation of both children and their parents in the research endeavor.
2.2 │ Ethics consideration
After receiving approval from the Research Council and securing ethical clearance with the code of ethics IR.IAU.CHALUS.REC.1397.028 from the Bioethics Committee of Chalus Islamic Azad University, this study was initiated. The researcher provided a formal letter of introduction to education authorities, elucidating the research's objectives. Subsequently, during face-to-face interactions, the research objectives were communicated to potential participants who met the inclusion criteria. Following the solicitation of written informed consent from the participants, assurances were extended regarding the safety of the research and the preservation of participant anonymity. Additionally, participants were explicitly informed of their prerogative to withdraw from the study at any juncture without consequence.
2.3 │ Data collection
The instruments utilized for data collection in this investigation encompass demographic variables (such as gender, age, children's education level, father's education, mother's education, father's occupation, mother's occupation, and father's veteran percentage), the secondary traumatic stress scale, and the academic self-concept questionnaire.
Secondary traumatic stress scale, developed by Bride et al., (2004), comprises 17 items employing a Likert scale ranging from one (never) to five (very much) for responses [20]. The scale encompasses three subscales annoyance, avoidance, and arousal, with the total score derived from the cumulative scores of these subscales. Previous research by Bride et al., (2004) [20] has demonstrated the scale's reliability, convergent and divergent validity, and acceptable construct validity [21]. The Cronbach's alpha coefficient for the entire scale was reported as 0.93, with subscale values of 0.80 for annoyance, 0.87 for avoidance, and 0.83 for arousal [20]. The Persian version of the secondary traumatic stress scale was validated by Rezapour et al., (2017) among Iranian adolescents, confirming construct validity through factor analysis and demonstrating Cronbach's alpha coefficients of 0.891 for the total score, 0.748 for annoyance, 0.741 for avoidance, and 0.774 for arousal [7]. Notably, a substantial and significant correlation was observed among secondary traumatic stress scale factors [22], and convergent validity was established through correlations with anxiety, stress, and depression scores in the spouses and children of veterans, with a Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.92 in the spouses of veterans [7].
Academic self-concept, developed by Chen & Thompson (2004) and administered to 1612 Taiwanese students, consists of 15 questions evaluating an individual's mental self-image and self-concept across three levels general, school, and non-school. Respondents use a four-point Likert scale, ranging from completely disagree (1) to completely agree (4). The questionnaire yields both an overall score and scores for the individual subscales. The minimum score achievable on this test is 15, with a maximum score of 60. The reliability of the questionnaire was confirmed with a Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.84 for the entire instrument 0.86 for general self-concept, 0.75 for educational self-concept, and 0.55 for non-academic self-concept subscales [23]. The Persian version of the academic self-concept was standardized by Afsharzadeh et al., (2013), confirming validity through form validity, content validity, construct validity, and convergent validity. The questionnaire's reliability was also established with a Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.78 [24].
The study received approval from the research council and ethical clearance from the biological ethics committee of Islamic Azad Chalous University. Participants were assured of the research's safety, and the anonymity of research subjects was maintained through an introductory letter provided to education officials, elucidating the research's purpose. Non-random sampling was employed for participant selection, and the researcher was present during questionnaire completion to address any queries from research subjects.
2.4 │ Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses for this study were conducted utilizing the SPSS software package (version 16.0, SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Descriptive statistics were employed to present continuous variables in the form of the mean (standard deviation (SD)), while categorical variables were expressed as frequency (percentage). Linear regression tests were utilized to examine relationships between variables. All statistical tests were conducted as two-sided analyses, with a predetermined significance level set at 0.05.
3 │ Results
3.1 │ Participants’ characteristics
In the present study, Table 1 illustrates the involvement of 150 offspring of military veterans. Within this cohort, 52.80% were female, and 56.30% were enrolled in the twelfth grade. The educational background of fathers indicated that 46.50% possessed a diploma, while 32.40% of mothers held a diploma. In terms of occupation, 32.20% of fathers were employed, and a substantial 87.30% of mothers were engaged in employment.
3.2 │ The relationship between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept in children of veterans
As delineated in Table 1, the findings of this study revealed that the magnitude of secondary traumatic stress in the offspring of veterans averaged 43.97 (SD=13.80). Similarly, the academic self-concept level among these individuals was recorded at 40.15 (SD=17.09), indicating an average level of educational self-concept in the children of veterans.
As detailed in Table 2, the outcomes of the linear regression analysis indicated a statistically significant association between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept (P<0.01). Specifically, as secondary traumatic stress increased, there was a corresponding decrease in the level of academic self-concept.
4 │ Discussion
The findings of this investigation indicate an elevated level of secondary traumatic stress among the offspring of veterans, surpassing the mean. Conversely, the level of academic self-concept was found to be average. Statistical analysis demonstrated a noteworthy correlation between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept. Consequently, as secondary traumatic stress escalated, a corresponding reduction in the academic self-concept of students was observed.
The impact of secondary traumatic stress manifests in various psychological consequences among the offspring of veterans, leading to consequential psychological challenges within this demographic [25]. Notably, PTSD symptoms and their associated complications are not exclusive to veterans; rather, they extend to encompass their children and other family members as well [4, 26]. Within this context, emotional responses and challenges in learning are identified as potential sequelae of stress and secondary traumatic stress experienced by the children of veterans [27]. Onzo et al., (2016) posited that stress following a wartime incident significantly contributes to a decline in the academic performance of veterans' children, highlighting the intricate interplay between stress and academic outcomes [16]. Consequently, feelings of despondency, hopelessness, and educational underachievement are frequently observed in the offspring of veterans [28].
A pivotal determinant of academic success in students is the cultivation of a positive self-concept [19]. Notably, anxiety and depression emerge as prevalent manifestations of PTSD in the offspring of veterans, thereby exerting a deleterious influence on their academic performance [28]. A study by Rutter et al., (2022) established a correlation between diminished self-esteem and reduced self-efficacy in students, positing that individuals with lower self-esteem possess a less comprehensive understanding of themselves [27]. Consequently, fostering psychological well-being assumes significant importance, as it serves to ameliorate psychological symptoms and enhance students' self-concept and self-esteem [29].
Table 1. Demographic characteristics and secondary-traumatic stress and academic self-concept score (N=150).
|
Frequency (%) or Mean (SD) |
Demographic characteristics |
|
Gender |
|
Male |
68 (47.20) |
Female |
75 (52.80) |
Children education level |
|
8th year |
13 (9.20) |
9th year |
19 (13.40) |
10th year |
16 (11.30) |
11th year |
14 (9.90) |
12th year |
80 (56.30) |
Father education level |
|
Elementary |
20 (14.10) |
Cycle |
9 (6.30) |
High school |
10 (7.00) |
Diploma |
66 (46.50) |
Associate Degree |
15 (10.60) |
University |
22 (15.50) |
Mother education level |
|
Elementary |
41 (28.90) |
Cycle |
30 (21.10) |
High school |
18 (12.70) |
Diploma |
48 (32.40) |
Associate Degree |
7 (4.90) |
Fathers job |
|
Self-employed |
32 (22.50) |
Unemployed |
20 (14.10) |
Employee |
46 (32.20) |
Retired |
44 (31.00) |
Mothers job |
|
Housewife |
124 (87.30) |
Employee |
11 (7.70) |
Self-employed |
7 (5.00) |
Veteran percentage |
|
<25 |
67 (47.20) |
25 to 50 |
40 (28.20) |
>50 |
35 (24.60) |
Secondary traumatic stress |
|
Annoyance |
13.51 (SD=4.52) |
Avoidance |
17.54 (SD=6.04) |
Arousal |
12.91 (SD=5.63) |
Total |
43.97 (SD=13.80) |
Academic self-concept |
|
General |
12.66 (SD=2.16) |
School |
21.21 (SD=4.21) |
Non-school |
5.28 (SD=1.24) |
Total |
40.15 (SD=17.09) |
Values are given as mean (SD) for continuous variables and frequency (%) for categorical variables.
Table 2. The relationship between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept in children of veterans (N=150).
|
Mean (SD) |
P-value |
Secondary traumatic stress |
43.97 (SD=13.80) |
<0.01 |
Academic self-concept |
40.15 (SD=17.09) |
P-value was obtained with a linear regression test.
The research conducted by Rezapour Mirsaleh et al., (2016) revealed a noteworthy inverse relationship of statistical significance between secondary traumatic stress and both academic performance and motivation. Specifically, heightened symptoms of PTSD were associated with a concomitant decline in academic motivation [30]. Expanding on this theme, Boffa et al., (2018) observed an increased prevalence of despair and distorted self-concept among the offspring of individuals with PTSD, underscoring the psychological ramifications of such conditions [31]. In a similar vein, Habibzadeh et al., (2016) established that PTSD significantly impacts students' sense of cohesion and self-concept. Moreover, a discernible distinction was identified between two groups—children of veterans and their counterparts without such familial background—about their sense of cohesion and academic self-concept [32].
Raeisoon et al., (2014) conducted research, determining a positive correlation between elevated self-concept and self-esteem in students and their academic achievements [33]. Similarly, Nasiri et al., (2017) demonstrated, through their study, that an accurate academic self-concept contributes to enhanced consistency in students' academic performance. This correlation is rooted in the premise that a precise comprehension of stressful circumstances augments self-efficacy [34]. Consequently, social support mechanisms play a pivotal role in fostering accurate self-concept among students [35]. Additionally, interventions centered around motivation management training have exhibited efficacy in augmenting both academic vitality and academic self-concept among students, as indicated by relevant studies [36].
4.1 │ Limitations
The inherent limitation of employing a cross-sectional design in this study impedes the comprehensive assessment of long-term effects or temporal changes over an extended duration. Additionally, potential sampling bias arises from the composition of the sample of children of veterans, rendering it possibly non-representative of the entire population. If the sample predominantly comprises individuals from a specific region or demographic, the external validity of the findings may be compromised, limiting their generalizability to the broader population of children with veteran backgrounds. These constraints underscore the need for cautious interpretation and consideration of the study's scope of broader demographic contexts.
4.2 │ Recommendations for future research
Undertake longitudinal research endeavors to thoroughly investigate the dynamic interrelationship between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept over an extended period. Employing this methodological approach is crucial for attaining a more nuanced understanding of the enduring effects. Integrate both quantitative and qualitative research methods to gain a comprehensive perspective on the experiences of children of veterans. Qualitative data, specifically, can offer richer insights into the lived experiences and perceptions of the participants. Systematically examine the effectiveness of interventions or support programs designed to alleviate the impact of secondary traumatic stress on academic self-concept in children of veterans. Investigate the outcomes of specific interventions to derive evidence-based practices that can inform future initiatives and support frameworks.
5 │ Conclusions
The findings of this study underscore a discernible correlation between secondary traumatic stress and the academic self-concept observed in the children of veterans. Notably, academic success emerges as a significant factor contributing to the enhancement of self-concept among this demographic. In light of these insights, educational administrators and stakeholders must cultivate a precise and nuanced comprehension of this relationship. Consequently, the development of educational and support programs should be undertaken with a comprehensive understanding of the psychological needs of students, particularly those with a familial connection to veterans. This strategic approach ensures a targeted and effective response to the intricate interplay between secondary traumatic stress and academic self-concept in this specific cohort.
Acknowledgements
Not applicable.
Authors’ contributions
Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work: MH, MT, RK, RM; Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content: MH, MT, RK, RM; Final approval of the version to be published: MH, MT, RK, RM; Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved: MH, MT, RK, RM.
Funding
Self-funded.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
After receiving approval from the Research Council and securing ethical clearance with the code of ethics IR.IAU.CHALUS.REC.1397.028 from the Bioethics Commit-tee of Chalus Islamic Azad University, this study was initiated. Before participation, all individuals provided informed consent after receiving detailed information about the study's aims. Participants were explicitly in-formed of their right to withdraw from the study at any time if they chose to do so.
Competing interests
We do not have potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and publication of this article.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used during the current study are available from the corresponding author on request.
Using artificial intelligent chatbots
None.
This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License (CC BY-NC 4.0).
© 2024 The Author(s).